Written by: Gordon Alford | Co-founder of InsuRabbit.com | Updated on: October 12, 2026
How often should you shop around for renters insurance? At least once a year, ideally a few weeks before your policy renews. And don’t wait for renewal if you move, your premium goes up, or you buy something valuable.
The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) suggests that renters and owners alike review all of their insurance policies every year. As a result, a short annual check can help you keep the right coverage at a fair price.
Quick answer: Review your renters policy once a year before renewal. In addition, shop for new quotes when you move, sign a new lease, add or lose a roommate, make a major purchase, or see a noticeable rate increase.
Why renters should review their insurance regularly
Many renters buy a policy when they sign a lease and then never look at it again. However, both your life and your insurance options change over time.
First, your belongings change. You may buy a new laptop, furniture, or a bike, and each purchase can raise the value of what you need to protect. The NAIC calls a home inventory “the best way to determine the appropriate level of coverage needed for contents.” If you are not sure your limits still fit, read about whether you might be underinsured as a renter.
Second, your living situation changes. A new apartment, a new roommate, or a new city can change both your risks and your price.
Third, insurers change their rates and discounts. Consequently, the company that offered the best value when you first signed up may not offer it today.
Why you need your own renters policy
Before comparing quotes, it helps to remember what you are buying. The NAIC explains that your landlord’s insurance doesn’t cover the things you own. Similarly, New York’s Department of Financial Services states that a landlord does not insure a tenant’s personal property and warns that tenants could be held liable if someone is injured in their home.
Most renters policies therefore combine two core protections, according to the NAIC: personal property coverage and liability coverage. In addition, some policies help pay for temporary housing if a covered loss makes your rental unlivable. For a full breakdown, see our guide to what renters insurance covers.
When to shop for renters insurance
Although an annual review covers most situations, certain events call for a fresh comparison right away.
Before your policy renews
Your renewal is the most natural time to shop. Check your renewal date, and start comparing quotes a few weeks ahead so you have time to decide. If your premium went up, ask your insurer why before you renew.
When you move or sign a new lease
A move changes your address, your building, and often your risks. Therefore, update your insurer, confirm that your coverage follows you, and compare quotes for the new location. Our guide on telling your insurer when you move explains the steps. Also, read your new lease, because some landlords set minimum coverage requirements; here is more on why landlords require renters insurance.
When a roommate moves in or out
Roommate changes can affect who your policy covers. For that reason, review your policy whenever your household changes, and learn whether roommates should share a renters policy.
After a major purchase
New electronics, jewelry, or musical instruments can push your belongings past your coverage limit. Moreover, Washington’s regulator notes that coverage for certain items, such as jewelry, may pay less than their full worth, so ask your insurer whether you need extra coverage.
When your rate jumps
A noticeable price increase at renewal is a clear signal to compare. Even if you stay with your current insurer, a few competing quotes show you whether your price is reasonable.
How to compare renters insurance quotes
Once you decide to shop, a consistent process makes your comparison fair and useful.
- Take a home inventory. List your belongings and their approximate value. Washington’s insurance regulator suggests recording a video of each room and keeping your inventory in the cloud so you can reach it after a loss.
- Choose your coverage amounts. Decide on personal property and liability limits that fit your belongings and your situation. Our guide to choosing the right renters coverage can help.
- Compare equal coverage. Ask each insurer to quote the same limits and deductible. Otherwise, a lower price may simply reflect less coverage.
- Check how claims are paid. The NAIC explains that actual cash value coverage pays what an item was worth at the time of the loss, while replacement cost coverage pays to replace it with a new one. Ask each insurer which method its quote uses, because the difference can matter after a loss.
- Ask about discounts. According to the NAIC, many insurers offer discounts for fire or burglar alarms. In addition, Washington’s regulator suggests asking about bundling renters and auto insurance.
- Research the insurer. Washington’s regulator also recommends comparing complaint data, so you can avoid companies with a poor record of handling claims or service.
For more ways to save, see our tips for getting a better deal on renters insurance, and our guide to comparing insurance quotes online.
What renters insurance usually does not cover
Every policy has exclusions, and shopping is a good time to review them. Notably, Washington’s regulator states that damage from earthquakes, floods, landslides, and sinkholes is typically excluded on standard renter policies.
Flood deserves special attention. The Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) notes that renters insurance usually doesn’t cover flood damage, and that renters in participating communities can buy flood insurance through the National Flood Insurance Program, with contents coverage of up to $100,000. For related gaps, read whether renters insurance covers water damage.
How much does renters insurance cost?
Renters insurance is often one of the more affordable types of coverage. In a recent consumer article, the NAIC stated that an average policy costs between $15 and $30 a month — with options as low as $5 per month. However, your price depends on your location, coverage limits, deductible, and other factors. For more recent pricing context, see our breakdown of annual renters insurance costs.
Frequently asked questions
How often should I compare renters insurance quotes?
The NAIC suggests reviewing all of your insurance policies once a year. In addition, compare quotes whenever you move, your rate rises noticeably, or your belongings or household change.
Can I switch renters insurance in the middle of my policy?
Generally, yes. However, terms vary by insurer, so check your policy for refund and cancellation rules. Above all, make sure your new policy starts before your old one ends, so you never have a gap in coverage.
Does my landlord’s insurance cover my belongings?
No. According to the NAIC, your landlord’s insurance doesn’t cover the things you own. You need your own renters policy to protect your belongings and your liability.
Does renters insurance cover flood damage?
Usually not. FEMA notes that renters insurance usually doesn’t cover flood damage, but renters in participating communities can buy separate flood coverage for their belongings through the National Flood Insurance Program.
Do I need new renters insurance when I move?
You need to update your policy to your new address, and a move is a good time to compare quotes. Check with your insurer about how your coverage applies during and after the move.
Is renters insurance worth it if I don’t own much?
Many renters underestimate what they own. The NAIC points out that even modest belongings can add up to thousands of dollars, and a policy also includes liability coverage. A home inventory helps you decide.
The bottom line
So, how often should you shop around for renters insurance? Review your policy at least once a year before it renews. Beyond that, shop again when you move, your household changes, you make a major purchase, or your rate rises.
Ultimately, the right policy is the one that fits your belongings, your budget, and your risks, not simply the cheapest one. If you own a home instead, see our guide on how often to shop for homeowners insurance. When you are ready, you can compare renters insurance quotes on InsuRabbit at no cost.